Last time I checked there were quite a few shenanigans going on with ownership and transfers, seeming very shifty. But since the original Syncthing for Android is abandoned I feel like i have no choice… Has anybody spotted major red flags or was it just a messy maintainer transfer?
I don’t trust anything that hasn’t been around for a while at this point.
FYI there is also BasicSync, it’s working well for me
This is what I have been using ever since. Minimalist code base, works great. But: The project essentially rests on the shoulders of one single dev.
Very true (with most f-droid apps too), but hopefully thanks to the minimalist code base it’ll be easier (even for others) to review and mantain. I even prefer using the web UI since it’s the standard interface on desktop/server as well
It has worked very well for me, and there hasn’t been any weird shenanigans as of right now. It was a bit messy but it’s all good! If you are very paranoid, I think you can use Termux with the Linux version of Syncthing (or hey, go all the way and experiment with a Linux phone if you’re daring!)
I won’t say I followed the drama closely but I think it ended up being nothing more than a messy transfer.
I almost hate to say it but in my experience 9/10 times you see a vague but loud “drama” surrounding a FOSS project it ends up being smoke without fire. Like I think there are just a bunch of bored people out there, and for some reason this is their reality TV.
I’ve been using the fork for a year now without issue.
Says the fascist tesseract dev
Holy shit that’s the guy ? thanks for calling him out
Adding custom tags on users is a great feature which helps me keep people identified.
Are we sure that’s the guy at least ? it’s not just a hunch, is it ?
I’m sure, I did a deep dive when this came out and saw the posts that confirmed my suspicions.
They have since deleted those but I’m sure there are screenshots of what was deleted somewhere.
There are plenty of other people that claimed this is a known alt, and Kirk loves to defend the fascist tesseract dev and the practice of using a hidden censor list to silence the voices of human rights activists, trans people and anti-fascists.
Thanks for documenting this
Am I missing some lore here?
This post sums up the ordeal well
https://lemmy.world/post/49778547
Kirk is one of the dev’s many alts and was caught censoring Lemmy via a hidden censor list that included mainly human rights activists, trans people, and anti-fascists.
So the fact that they’re saying that
9/10 times you see a vague but loud “drama” surrounding a FOSS project it ends up being smoke without fire.
Is incredible, I guess they are trying to whitewash their image.
I sure as hell hope it will turn out like you say. That said, I need to remind everyone that the guy responsible for the xzutils backdoor did not plant the payload right away. He took months supplying the project with legitimate code before pushing his malicious commit. So “shit has been fine so far” isn’t exactly reassuring; whether the new maintainer can be trusted remains to be seen months, if not years from now. And I won’t be around for that. Trust is a fragile commodity: it’s hard to build, easy to lose, and even harder to regain.
The XZ Utils situation is actually a great example of the 9/10 situations I’m talking about because the attackers boosted drama in in order to socially pressure the developer and break his confidence, which eventually pushed him into ceding control of the project.
[The] used sock puppetry in a pressure campaign against the original maintainer of XZ Utils, eventually being given maintainer permissions on the project. Source
Over the next year, they would largely take control of the project from its original maintainer, Lasse Collin, a change driven in part by nagging emails sent to Collin by a handful users complaining about slow updates. Source
That is not what happened here. As anyone can verify in the Syncthing forum thread that started all of this, people were wondering one day why suddenly the old maintainer’s Github was unavailable and why maintenance of the project had quietly switched hands without any communication with the community. This left people justifiably wondering what had happened here: miscommunication during the handover of the project, or something more sinister - a user account compromise + hostile takeover. I’m not saying one is true or the other. But since Syncthing has become a security critical part of my infrastructure, I’ve opted to stay away from researchxxl’s Syncthing-fork for Android. Like I said: trust is a fickle creature.
My point is that the presence of drama is not correlated to the presence of a threat; and often times in FOSS-world (where many devs are volunteers) the drama itself is the actual attack vector.
bruh seriously you crashed out hard over “FOSS drama”
? I said I use the fork without issue
Tesseract dev still can’t accept that he was the asshole.
Wait wait wait, a developer blocked you on Lemmy and your reaction is to stalk them around the internet calling them an asshole?
Take a good look at your behavior. You don’t even have any evidence that I am Admiral Patrick you just saw some other wannabe harasser say it.






