• GrackleBirb@lemmy.ca
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      7 hours ago

      The continued existence of Israel is not “predicated on death” - the settlers and Bibi do not reflect all of Israel and many Israelis are appalled by the situation in Gaza and the West Bank settlements which is why the recent elections went the way they did. You also ignore the fact that 20 percent of Israeli citizens are Arabs and Muslims themselves and their parties also have gained support.

      No one is going to depopulate Tel Aviv and send everyone back to (insert mythical place here because modern Israeli Jews come from many places - most of them not in Europe as Ashkenazim are not the majority) - Israel will continue to exist and needs to completely change how they engage with the Palestinians but there is no road to pre-1948 just as modern Canada won’t be depopulated and ceded back to its original inhabitants.

      • fif-t@fedia.io
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        3
        ·
        7 hours ago

        We’re not going to agree on this.

        If they were actually appalled, the approval rates of genocidal behaviour wouldn’t be so high (poll is from 2025, haven’t seen a newer one, feel free to find it)

        I’d like a bit of whatever you’re smoking, because in the latest Israeli elections, none of the candidates were any better or substantially different than Benjamin Netanyahu on the topic of Palestine. In fact, I saw that many considered him to be “too pro-Palestine”. There was also an attempt to ban “Arab parties” entirely. Gadi Eisenkot currently has not formed a government because him and his party and any affiliates refuse to form a coalition with the so-called “Arab parties”, to the point there was even a Rabbi who said anyone who would collaborate with the “Arab Parties” should be killed Gadi Eisenkot is also against a Palestinian state entirely.

        You also use the Zionist and Israeli framing of “Arab-Israeli”. Say what they really are: second class Palestinian citizens of the apartheid state of Israel.

        Fundamentally, Israel will cease to be Israel in the way that Israelis want it to be if a demographic majority of Jews is not maintained. How is that demographic majority going to be maintained? (hint: it’s not peaceful, nice, or pretty) You either have a democratic state of all its people, or you have a Jewish ethnostate. You cannot have both.

        A two state solution is also untenable, considering the state encouraged (and protected) settlements and settlers that have changed the “facts on the ground”, which is what their goal is/was.

        Israel needs to be dismantled at least as (if not more) thoroughly than the third reich was in Germany.

        • Avid Amoeba@lemmy.ca
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          6 hours ago

          I mean, there’s 18% who don’t support cleansing. And from them there’s probably a subfraction that genuinely support a form of peaceful coexistence. So probably tens to hundreds of thousands. One could say that’s not an insignificant number if in the hundreds of thousands. 😄 Does it matter? Probably not given 5.9M want ethnic cleansing.