Best music I’ve ever heard in a game up until Automata.
Gameplay is it’s big weakness.
The old man strength had a certain charm to it versus the brother, but I’m sure Replicant is a fine version.
Do you have a particular reason to play Gestalt over Replicant?
Gameplay is definitely better. The story is the same (+ some additional things). And I’m going to disagree with the other commenters here, I think the brother figure works better than the father figure. IMO the role was pretty obviously intended to be a brother, and the change to father instead of brother was only done for the US market, anyways.
Everyone being roughly the same age is far more natural, and the character development / changes towards the second half are even more gut-wrenching IMO.
But, no matter if Gestalt or Replicant: I absolutely love it. Yeah it shows its age and there’s a lot of running around, but goddamn the story is absolutely timeless and just such a terribly devastating tragedy. We don’t even need to talk about the music.
I played Automata first, and when I’m recommending the games, I also recommend this order. The story and music are almost as good, but the gameplay is so much better. That way people can get invested, and then accept the clunkier mechanics to experience Replicant. Other way round is a tough sell, even if you get more out of Automata after Replicant.
I’m feeling a little obtuse tonight and not sure I’m following; do you recommend replicant or gestalt? I adored Automata and have been looking at getting replicant for awhile
Not who you asked but they recommend Replicant due to the brother.
But I’m not sure why we’re not talking about the remake, which is NieR Replicant™ ver.1.22474487139… If the old ones are too aged then the remake is great.
Right on thanks. My brain didn’t want to brain for a bit. Lol
The remake is the one on my wish list, so that works beautifully. Thanks!
Hi, I’m the person you originally asked. Yes, I recommend Replicant ver.1.22474487139…
Due to the brother, the additional content, and the much improved gameplay.
I’m excited to get it! Thanks!
Have fun! It’s a ride. Make sure to avoid spoilers :D
Love Papa Nier, even if he looks like Gary Busey. This was the game that changed my opinion on English dubs, that maybe they aren’t so bad. The music of the Junk Heap is burned into my mind.
Great music, interesting characters, repetitive gameplay and lots of running around.
I really like it. Love the soundtrack. Compared to Replicant I think dad Nier suits the story better (except for the ending).
The gameplay tho isn’t great. It’s a bit better in the Replicant remaster.
I like it, I like it a lot
My favorite version of the game. I even imported the Japanese Xbox 360 version with the same title.
The Father character is simply more compelling to me, even though the writing makes him a bit awkward at times. It has a special charm to it that I don’t get from the Brother story.
The gameplay is okay, but thats standard Cavia.
I played the original PS3 version (exactly one week before the remake was announced) and even with the technical limitations of the time, I liked it a lot. I actually prefer the story of that one compared to Automata.
No idea what that is, but now that I saw it, I’m curious to go find out.





