…
Some schools of thought have defined economic security as having two sides: strategic autonomy, which seeks to limit dependence on potentially coercive partners through diversification and resilient supply chains; and strategic indispensability, which seeks to develop goods or services that other nations cannot easily replace, making it harder for them to coerce or decouple from you.
…
For Canada, it is obvious where our strengths lie; indeed, it has been revealed. In the trade war with the United States, the products they had the most difficulty replacing domestically or from other trading partners were oil, potash, uranium, nickel, and aluminum, as well as natural gas in some regional markets.
…
Thinking proactively, how can Canada use its energy and minerals to make itself indispensable to more allies?
The obvious answer is to export more oil, LNG, uranium, potash, and minerals to trading partners in Asia and Europe. The commodity shocks arising from the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine and the 2026 disruption of the Strait of Hormuz make this both possible and imperative.
…
There have been further investments in critical minerals production that make sense only from a strategic, rather than economic lens. It has become well understood that China has developed monopolies in a variety of critical minerals that has given it strategic indispensability in the international system. In an attempt to reduce their dependence, most Western nations have put out lists of minerals in which they plan to intervene to secure supply. NATO put out its own list in December 2024, and Canada has catalysed around it, in particular through its G7 Critical Minerals Resilience and Production Alliance.
…
[Canada] made significant investments in germanium, gallium, antimony, graphite, scandium, as well as lithium, rare earths, cobalt, and aluminum, with the most important probably being the major investment in July in Teck’s Trail Operations in British Columbia, one of the world’s largest fully integrated polymetallic smelting and refining complexes. These represent costs, not sources of revenue, but they are worth it to make ourselves more important to our allies.
…
Canada’s natural resources are indeed a source of power, and should be cultivated as such. But that doesn’t mean the wealth they generate is secondary. As Canada is pushed into spending more on defence in this fraught geopolitical era, the most significant source of additional income will come from growing its energy and resource exports.
…
Within this framework, expanding energy and minerals production and growing global market share are ends in themselves, and essential to making Canada, and its allies, more prosperous and secure. The opposite is true: restricting Canadian resource development has negative political and economic repercussions that are difficult to tolerate. That is why telling the German Chancellor in August 2022 that there was no business case for Canadian LNG when that important ally was trying desperately to minimize reliance on Russian natural gas was so painful to many of us.
…
Many nations seek to become indispensable in order to exploit that dependence coercively. That is not, and must not become, Canada’s objective. We should never weaponize our energy and resource exports. We should aim instead to become the most reliable, predictable, and commercially competitive source of raw materials our allies and competitors can find.
…
It’s time to reflect that in our security and foreign policies explicitly.
…



This is what the op-ed also asks if i get it right. It’s not about just selling the resources, but also to whom, and to vertically integrate supply chains which then remain sufficiently under Canadian control or, at least, under like-minded partners’ control.
Canada has been investing also in refining capacities in recent years, so that is certainly a first major step, and the investment plans the government has presented this summer contain some very useful initiatives imho.
But I guess it’s not all about profitability. Profit margins in this this industry are very volatile (mainly due to volatile commodity prices). It is important, however, to maintain these businesses for geopolitical reasons. We have seen China blocking rare earths exports for political and economic coercion very often. By investing in rare earths refining capacities and similar businesses, Canada and others (Greenland and some African countries are investing here heavily afaik) are able to shield themselves from such coercion, even if the businesses themselves aren’t necessarily too profitable.
But that’s just my 2 cents.
That’s why it harms the whole country when some special interest groups keep putting up constant road blocks to our resources