First person melee combat is the only way to make an FPS worse. This is why the stealth archer is the most popular build in Skyrim.
While I agree, cod did have knife only builds.
The comments disagreeing seem to prove your point. Imagine trying to fit a slow combat style into COD.
Stealth archer being the most popular build in Skyrim has nothing to do with first person melee being bad, and has more of bethesda not cooking a great melee combat yet somehow managed to pull a very good stealth archer archtype
Melee being mediocre is something the series always struggled with not just Skyrim yet Oblivion and Morrowind archery isn’t as popular, because in these games archery was on a similar level to melee, mediocre or even worse
Many games have great first person melee:
Darktide
Vermintide 2
Dying light
Elderborn
Avowed
Cyberpunk 2077 would like a word.
Kingdom come?
That’s… Certainly an opinion.
I always pick the melee option if it’s viable - great fun can be had bringing a knife to a gunfight
On one hand, I’m down.
On the other, this would be so hard to get right while preserving any CoD feel that I don’t think they’d land it well.
well, if it doesn’t preserve the CoD feel, it might have a chance
The CoD feel is what made this franchise into a juggernaut.
Engine feel yes, cod feel no.
The engine doesn’t make game feel on its own. Their engine was largely just Id Tech for the longest time, and to my knowledge, it’s still built on those bones. You can make Unity feel like Call of Duty if you wanted, and you can also make it feel like Super Smash Bros. Melee.
deleted by creator
Crusade of Duty sounds dope actually. Captain FischerPrice showing up screaming ‘Deus vult’ would be hilarious.
Religious folk might be up and arms but when aren’t they.
On a real note, Assassins Creed has had a pretty unassailed monopoly on high budget historical jaunts. Wish more was done with that from any company.
If you haven’t already, check out Kingdom Come: Deliverance, especially 2.
Isn’t that exactly what Chivalry is?
I could see describing chiv 2 as medieval BF but I’m not seeing cod anywhere in it. More depth to the combat than any bf or cod has ever officially offered…Warhaven is more like what I imagine any of the studios involved with BF/CoD to make for a medieval game.
Chivalry 2 definitely gave more cod vibez, depends on the map, at least around releas3
I don’t know, I played it for a few hours before saying ‘ugh this feels just like call of duty’ then stopped.
I’ve invented a fictional world based around burgeoning, unreliable firearms often weighed against melee weaponry and crossbows, with a few occasional unrealistic elements like steampunk legged spider tanks. I’ll admit, it felt like a dream goal for a Battlefield game to be based around it, letting the technological limitations of the kingdoms mesh with whatever makes good gameplay balance, so that both axes and muskets have a fun tactical appeal to them.
In slightly tangential news, horror asym Dead by Daylight recently added a pistol to the powers of Art the Clown, and it’s interesting how they built up the balance of that in a game that often just gives killers machetes and throwing items.
Sounds neat, reminds me a little of the book 1632






