Stealth archer being the most popular build in Skyrim has nothing to do with first person melee being bad, and has more of bethesda not cooking a great melee combat yet somehow managed to pull a very good stealth archer archtype
Melee being mediocre is something the series always struggled with not just Skyrim yet Oblivion and Morrowind archery isn’t as popular, because in these games archery was on a similar level to melee, mediocre or even worse
I don’t agree that it’s a very good archetype because it depends pretty heavily on the NPC AI that forgets what’s happening if it can’t locate the origin of an arrow within so many seconds and then just goes back to doing whatever they were doing before they were shot. Whereas for any other approach to combat, you need to end it immediately or deal with the enemy’s response.
Stealth archer being the most popular build in Skyrim has nothing to do with first person melee being bad, and has more of bethesda not cooking a great melee combat yet somehow managed to pull a very good stealth archer archtype
Melee being mediocre is something the series always struggled with not just Skyrim yet Oblivion and Morrowind archery isn’t as popular, because in these games archery was on a similar level to melee, mediocre or even worse
Many games have great first person melee:
Darktide
Vermintide 2
Dying light
Elderborn
Avowed
I don’t agree that it’s a very good archetype because it depends pretty heavily on the NPC AI that forgets what’s happening if it can’t locate the origin of an arrow within so many seconds and then just goes back to doing whatever they were doing before they were shot. Whereas for any other approach to combat, you need to end it immediately or deal with the enemy’s response.