My earlier comment on why pre-release reviews are a useless metric: https://lemmy.world/post/54554541/26937476
I’m sure the user reviews will still be a solid 9/10 or higher,
I actually didn’t expect it to be that low, even if you account for user bombing type reviews, this is still not a 9/10.
Most of the complaints seem to be about Rockstar copying the mechanics and aspects of RDR2 into GTA, which clashes with the typical playstyle of GTA.
Top legitimate complaints are probably:
- The story and characters are lackluster
- The criminal profile system punishes you heavily for doing crime spree stuff
- Crime activities and the ability to choose want you want to do are limited, especially with regards to the story
- FPS drops even at a 30 FPS target and a handful of glitches
Anyway, I think it’ll probably adjust to maybe a 7/10 or 8/10 in a couple months or after the PC release, especially as more people play the game for themselves and put their own review up.
On Metacritic anyone can make a review and rate the game, even those who did not buy it. I never cared about the user score on Metacritic. Steam is a better place for user scores, because a) only those who purchased the game are eligible to rate the game, and b) at least some of the detected unrelated review bombs are filtered out (but still can be read if you want). It’s not perfect, but at least on paper it makes more sense as real user voices are giving ratings. Unlike on Metacritic. Metacritic is like Twitter.
I’m so confused. If I leave GT6 a bad review Ive joined the rights crusade against woke bullshit but saved gaming by the lefts standards from becoming corpo slop
If I leave a 5 star review I’m a corporate bottlicking sellout and yet woke at the same time
Both sides need to STFU play the games you want.
Games 5 stars BTW
I see it as a good thing when we can de-politicize something that should never have been political to begin with
In my opinion, you should not care how others judge your for leaving a rating on a game. Give the review you think about the game, be honest. That is what matters most to me.
So it’s being used review bombed by both the right and the left .
The right is the typical woke bullshit like buying your virtual girlfriend flowers and a necklace.
The left for its corporatism.
Both of these groups need to get over themselves.
It’s a 70-100 game that is easily going to give you that many hours of entertainment for your money. . both sides are so anal retentive over GTA
I think it’ll probably adjust to maybe a 7/10 or 8/10 in a couple months or after the PC release.
Why would reviews go up for PC? Is it going to be a different game? It’s not like the it’s a buggy mess, the majority of the criticism is of the bullshit restrictions, the characters, overall story, and the outdated mechanics that haven’t changed significantly since the first GTA. I don’t think that’ll change on PC launch.
Why are people insisting on relying on reviews that don’t require a verified purchase?

The absolute hate boner Lemmy has for GTA is frankly hilarious to me
I know it’s just weird. Its the typical lame corporate hate, 30 fps, digital only bs argument that’s just as weak as the rights woke bs. Like asmongold bitching about buying your virtual girlfriend flowers and a necklace.
You know like how you are supposed to treat the woman in your life or am I just old at 48? And treating women nicely is old. School?
Seriously I hate that my daughter is getting into dating age territory if this is the manosphere bullshit is this prevalent nowadays
The game does a great job immersing us into its reality and that mirror to ours really hurts some people’s feelings. It’s also like people forgot the satirical aspect of gta.
I am overly delighted, that when you “go to bed” and auto puts you to look at your phone in bed. Theyre making fun of us, and I love it. Scroll the DOOM!
I just read that a person working at Publix has already seen a rise in men buying flowers for their partner. Idk if it’s true but I hope this game is secretly teaching kids to be good men.
And yet sad at the same time that they need a game to teach them
Someone needs to teach them. If it’s not their dads or movies it’ll be a game, and that’s fine.
My hate boner is more for Rockstar and the way it treats employees and fans. More of a hate semi, really.
Totally valid, I understand anyone who doesn’t want to engage with it with what happened there
I do want to share the fired employees themselves don’t want you to reject the game on that reason alone though
https://thisweekinvideogames.com/news/fired-rockstar-games-staff-ask-players-not-to-boycott-gta-vi/
Huh, I guess I missed OP’s notes. I’m watching the right-wing chuds self-destruct over not being able to hire prostitutes, being able to buy your girlfriend groceries, and having scenes with very tame gay overtones, and it’s so obvious with all of that review bombing, the user score isn’t worth anything one way or another.
Seems like it’s going to be a pretty decent game and that’s about as much attention as I’m giving it until it is $20 on sale on PC.
There’s more post hating it than loving it. But i guess people who love it are busy playing.
I just want a GTA game in Carcer, dammit. The Smileys need to make a return, especially Fug.
Yeah, this is much more accurate.
The main reason I posted Metacritic was because of the previous sledge thread of people arguing over the critic reviews being a useful metric. I still think it’ll land a little lower on Steam as the PC reviews tend to be more harsh.
Hate boner? These kids love this shit.
if this is how the gta 6 discourse is gonna be, elder scrolls 6 is going to end in literal wars
most of the people who play gta 6 does not play elder scrolls
but the elder scrolls community is much more volitile than gta community
Same as OP.
I did play each previous gta, had solid fun. I still do expect this is, (or be after patches?) 8+ or 9/10. Even after wtf 2/10 score to price ration - I even look at it without cutting monthly fee off singleplayer and at least 50% off promo, while probably not buy at all until free on epic store, coz rules.
But that’s just one drama… journalism shooting all 10/10, while the game is, in current state, very very very far away from that score. rockshit clearly paid freaky moniey to journalists and journalists clearly took it for it. I absolutely refuse to believe all of them felt it may be any 10/10 game… possibly few (as few of thousands over the world) got an orgasm on the game as it is huge, few other reviewers were simply dumb… but damn, some could expect any professionalism from them, and all went blind? not a fuacking chance. That much deserve boycott and hopefully a lawsuit for both rockshit and journalists. (aye lawsuit, that little cute drama with licence note, suuuuuure rockshit).
I still can’t believe a 30 FPS locked game can ever get a 10/10. Playing this in 30 FPS, is like watching a big blockbuster movie on a mobile screen. Imagine releasing The Odyssey as a mobile-only movie for the first year.
You mean blockbusters that play at 24 FPS?
60 would be better. I really only notice the issues with 30 when I’m driving tbh but now I just use auto drive so it doesn’t matter.
Auto drive?
Ah yes, the important metric that definitely reflects real life. Metacritic user scores.
Fans who didn‘t buy the game because it was too expansive or simply not accessible deserve a vote too. Metacritic isn‘t a shop like Steam where you are able to purchase everything you see anyway.
I do not subscribe to the notion only buyers get to vote on something you are confronted with regardless of whether you own it or not. Especially when it‘s shoved into your face on every website right now. It pollutes every virtual space. It‘s inescapable.
I support the general idea of an outlet like Metacritic where anyone gets to give an opinion on something. However most of those have to be bots so it‘s a little pointless. It‘s 2026 and we can‘t have nice things after all.
A vote on what?
Fans who didn‘t buy the game because it was too expansive or simply not accessible deserve a vote too.
No. They are not “users” of the game, therefore they do not deserve to vote. It’s like saying a Chinese citizen has the rights to vote in the US too. Or that someone who didn’t play the game has the right to give a rating.
You think 17,356 people are liars but you trust 152 people paid by the industry?
Yes. Because of the history of GTA. It’s a proven game with a dedicated fan base, no gaming studio is going to build a game on a billion dollar budget for over 12 years if there’s a slight chance it fails.
It’s being reviewed bombed by butthurt plebs from both the right and the left. For drastically different reasons but ultimately the same reason for their agenda that I as a gamer give no fucks about
I don’t trust any of them…
You trust a mob but not experts?
When the experts wage depends on this game not crashing, bringing the industry down with it?
It is difficult to get a
mancritic tounderstanddislike something when his salary depends upon his notunderstandingdisliking it.The game was nominated for most game awards before it was even out. That’s how unserious the industry is being.
Edit: to add that in this case I trust neither. I’m pretty sure GTA 6 is a good game, but there’s enough I’ve already seen to say it’s not an almost perfect game like the review scores claim.
Always, 100%. Here is why:
-
I’m not a paid expert myself, we’re a mob ourselves. The mob opinion will better reflect our own experiences.
-
The “experts” are paid by magazines which always hype up triple A titles to increase sales which in turn fuels more interest in the magazine that covers the title.
-
The mob has experts, too.
-
An expert aggregate score is completely pointless, if you trust one expert then you don’t need 152.
Here’s my hot take on that as a software engineer and gamer: Users are stupid.
The majority doesn’t know how games (or software for that matter) are made, what makes them good, or even what they like/dislike about them personally. They jump to conclusion or criticise things that you can’t change anything about without destroying other aspects of your game (the extremely common ‘absolutely not my type of game, but you owe me entertainment’ case).
Thanks to this stupidity, Steam reviews have degraded to a meme and ny advice to any game dev is to not blindly listen to user feedback. Question everything they tell you. You have to actively look for the valid points, or you will drown in bs that doesn’t get you anywhere. Or don’t listen at all, and just look what they do. If they play your game and you don’t have a gigantic marketing budget to thank for that, it’s a good game.
This. Users ruined gears of war series. Perfect example. Frag tagging. Frag tagging was so much fun, I turned it into a art form of sneaking behind players and had over 4k tags in my gears one career. The party I usually played with loved it when I was the last one alive with frags vs 2 of three players because they knew I’d get them
Frag tagging was the reason you checked your corners, didn’t go running blindly hoping to get a fast shotgun kill. Users complained it was to easy, it really wasn’t they just didn’t like that it threatened how they wanted to play it and that was by not checking corners.
So the devs listened and made it so most maps only have one grenade spot, upped the respawn time, made it so you had to basically be standing right next to them and shoteneds the detonation time so much that it was almost impossible to get away alive
A product which primarily brings satisfaction can be measured based on the satisfaction it brings. If you make a good game that nobody likes: your game is shit. If you make a good game that has a small but dedicated following, you have something like a “cult classic” but since the majority of people won’t enjoy it then obviously it’s better that it gets a low review by the general public.
-
For me, it’s a 6, which is better than average but not by much.
My issues with the game is mostly gameplay related. The controls are so sluggish, and walking around just isn’t fun. You can make it slightly better by turning on ‘always run’ but there is still so much intertia. And every action has way too much animation.
All the busywork with putting things in storage, making things out of storage, changing clothes, punch the punching bag, lift weights, etc etc.
Oh, and the radio channels all suck. Where’s the electonic music channel from previous games? And no funny talk radio?
And the cutscenes are so long. Great for people who love games with lots of story I guess.
I’m not saying the people who love it are wrong, they have different preferences, but very little of what I’m looking for in a game is there. Now, the game contains so much stuff that there is still a lot of fun to be had, which is why I’m still playing it.
I’ve been using auto drive to get around and then doing my own chores and what not while I wait. It’s been a good balance for me actually.
Also while I agree with you on the controls, I’m having a good time. I do think it would feel a little in 60FPS but I’m getting used to it.
In some ways it reminds me of Skyrim. I’m running around in some random direction and finding something weird to do. Yesterday it was fight a giant mutated crab off while I break into a safe.
The talk radio is cracking me up. Especially, The Wipe.
I’m not saying the people who love it are wrong, they have different preferences, but very little of what I’m looking for in a game is there.
I wish more people would be like this. And understand its a preference thing. In example I never got into Red Dead Redemption 2, because it looks so boring to me. But for some reason, I’m hyped that GTA 6 goes this route and even beyond it seems. I would love to see the living world around me coming to life, attack people, hide somewhere and see how the police is searching for me and the stuff.
no funny talk radio
You fucking what? I haven’t played it yet, and I might not be able to play it long if the framerate is as bad as it sounds, but I was so looking forward to the radio stations.
I still listen to previous games radios on commutes sometimes.
I don’t know why people are complaining about the frame rate. Maybe it’s because I’m playing on a LG C4 but to me I haven’t even noticed it.
But if I go back and play the original gears of war for Xbox 360. Something that I put a massive amount of time into I find it unplayable.
There maybe a slight hiccup every now and then but it’s been rare .
There are podcasts that are pretty fun and there is some talk radio I just don’t usually listen to it
I played on an xbox series s all day yesterday, and the game ran beautifully.
I havnt really listened to the radio much yet, nor gotten into the podcasts yet, but the little I have heard is funny. Am disappointed theres no punk radio channel.
There’s metal
I don’t know why people are complaining about the frame rate.
Because its not as fluid as 60 or higher. And it brings input lag with it too. Not only that, its also not locked in to 30, that means there are fluctuations, which feels bad to play when it happens. To me personally, this seems to be a good tradeoff in this case. However, not on the Series S.
I have the Series S and a PC and was looking forward to buy it twice, if its that good. But on Series S it has unacceptable framerates. Therefore will skip that.
But if I go back and play the original gears of war for Xbox 360. Something that I put a massive amount of time into I find it unplayable.
I had GTA 5 on launch on the XBOX 360. It was way worse back then, in fact every GTA launch was bad. This is the best GTA launch in framerate wise ever. The difference is, we are no longer on 360 and we are used to 60 fps, and know it could have been better. And often we have settings to decide if we want to play on performance or quality settings. Rockstar took this choice away from us (again understandable, looking at the scope of the game).
Framerate can be a real issue for some. Some are not that bothered by, but its a real issue to have with. Having issues in older generations or games is not an excuse to make the same mistake again. On a personal level, I think its a topic that is a bit too overblown, besides the Series S version.
I’m not trying to be insulting but there’s many who think the series S has hi dered game development this generation. And I am one who believe if a mistake to have a weaker console
Im on series s and played for 6 hours yesterday. It ran gorgeous…?
We have a series x too, and they both looked great, I didnt notice much difference. We werent sure how the series s would run it, and I was shocked it ran really well
I watched reviews I trust and it does not look acceptable (note not acceptable does not mean not playable) to me. What is acceptable is a personal thing, If you are okay with that, then its okay.
Maybe its a sort of motion sickness or something? I cant play Avowed or Atomfall because it makes me nauseous and headachey when turning the camera. I’ve turned down a lot more than those for framerate issues, but those are the ones I remember by name.
Beautiful screenshots, but absolutely unplayable.
I don’t know the frame rate in red dead redemption 2 bothers me but I still love the game.
I don’t know what rockstar is doing with GTA 6 but I don’t notice it like I do in RDR 2. I can’t wait for that to get a next gen update
There is some talking, but it’s in between songs. Often the news segments mentioning things in the game. So far I’ve been unable to find a talk radio station.
They also sometimes switch to a completely different song which provides soundtrack to the story. Probably great for people who love movies, but I find it annoying to have to manually find the channel again to override the soundtrack they added.
I think talk radio channels are just podcasts now
But the contol of gta games have always been ass. They could never figure out how people are suppised to move. The move like cars, or tanks. There is no free flow, it’s all scripted heavily. If you jump, you jump this far. I never understood how this is fun. Gta is also heavily used for roleplay, which, i’m not into at all, but i find it interesting. But a big aspect seems to be to be able to make your character not look like a weird puppet. I don’t think you should he able to “crash” on foot. It’s bumpy and weird. If you look at a game like deadlock, aure, it’s unrealistic, it has double jumps and air dashes, but the movement feels so right, the interactions with the enviroment is solid.
Yeah. Scripted is the word I think. It’s incredibly detailed in GTA 6, and you’re really impressed the first time you see the protagonist squeeze in to the door of the car because there’s another car in the way.
But after you’ve entered a car a few times, you really don’t want to watch it anymore, and just snapping into the car would be preferable, even though it’s not realistic.
The problem that has been known forever that this highlights to me at least it damages trust in professional reviewers stagnates the industry need ti do better and more importantly pisses off large segments of the paying customers who are increasingly finding the hobby less affordable.
Sure short term l8ne go up but long term the industry suffers
Removed by mod
What games do you like to play?
Removed by mod
So you don’t play video games, you just love to whine, got it. Thanks!
Choosing to ignore your hypocrisy while pointing out others. Is still hypocrisy
World is like, the least socialist instance, what are you on about?









