My earlier comment on why pre-release reviews are a useless metric: https://lemmy.world/post/54554541/26937476
I’m sure the user reviews will still be a solid 9/10 or higher,
I actually didn’t expect it to be that low, even if you account for user bombing type reviews, this is still not a 9/10.
Most of the complaints seem to be about Rockstar copying the mechanics and aspects of RDR2 into GTA, which clashes with the typical playstyle of GTA.
Top legitimate complaints are probably:
- The story and characters are lackluster
- The criminal profile system punishes you heavily for doing crime spree stuff
- Crime activities and the ability to choose want you want to do are limited, especially with regards to the story
- FPS drops even at a 30 FPS target and a handful of glitches
Anyway, I think it’ll probably adjust to maybe a 7/10 or 8/10 in a couple months or after the PC release, especially as more people play the game for themselves and put their own review up.


Always, 100%. Here is why:
I’m not a paid expert myself, we’re a mob ourselves. The mob opinion will better reflect our own experiences.
The “experts” are paid by magazines which always hype up triple A titles to increase sales which in turn fuels more interest in the magazine that covers the title.
The mob has experts, too.
An expert aggregate score is completely pointless, if you trust one expert then you don’t need 152.
Here’s my hot take on that as a software engineer and gamer: Users are stupid.
The majority doesn’t know how games (or software for that matter) are made, what makes them good, or even what they like/dislike about them personally. They jump to conclusion or criticise things that you can’t change anything about without destroying other aspects of your game (the extremely common ‘absolutely not my type of game, but you owe me entertainment’ case).
Thanks to this stupidity, Steam reviews have degraded to a meme and ny advice to any game dev is to not blindly listen to user feedback. Question everything they tell you. You have to actively look for the valid points, or you will drown in bs that doesn’t get you anywhere. Or don’t listen at all, and just look what they do. If they play your game and you don’t have a gigantic marketing budget to thank for that, it’s a good game.
This. Users ruined gears of war series. Perfect example. Frag tagging. Frag tagging was so much fun, I turned it into a art form of sneaking behind players and had over 4k tags in my gears one career. The party I usually played with loved it when I was the last one alive with frags vs 2 of three players because they knew I’d get them
Frag tagging was the reason you checked your corners, didn’t go running blindly hoping to get a fast shotgun kill. Users complained it was to easy, it really wasn’t they just didn’t like that it threatened how they wanted to play it and that was by not checking corners.
So the devs listened and made it so most maps only have one grenade spot, upped the respawn time, made it so you had to basically be standing right next to them and shoteneds the detonation time so much that it was almost impossible to get away alive
A product which primarily brings satisfaction can be measured based on the satisfaction it brings. If you make a good game that nobody likes: your game is shit. If you make a good game that has a small but dedicated following, you have something like a “cult classic” but since the majority of people won’t enjoy it then obviously it’s better that it gets a low review by the general public.